Jump to content
charly1979

Les Miserables ! Cant wait *May contain spoilers*

Recommended Posts

Ok so went to the BFI Imax today with DS to see the film. As already mentioned I am a complete Les Mis novice never having seen the stage show, and don't really know the tunes either....so my verdict of the film for what it's worth - there were some fantastic performances from the two australian boys....but I think it is overly long, the story line didn't hang together very well, I couldn't really understand the motives behind one character at all and it got very bogged down in the whole love story thing by which point I was getting fidgety and checking my watch....and wishing there was some dialogue...so would I go to see it again..no...once was enough for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just got back, we really enjoyed it. YS said he understood the story more from the film as you can see the actors expressions & hear the words clearer than the stage version.

 

We had tears falling in certain bits, I enjoyed Russell Crowe's singing more than I expected to (Javert is my favourite character). Anne Hathaway blew me away with her interpretation of Fantine, wonderfully done. I was quite impressed with Eddie Redmayne too, when he sang empty chairs at empty tables it really choked me up.

 

Hubby had more tears in his eyes than me, he wants to see it again next week! We bought the movie soundtrack whilst we were there. :D

 

I have a feeling that Les Mis - either film or stage show might be like marmite, you either love it or hate it. :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can see how it could be confusing if you don't know the show or haven't heard the songs, but I realised some things watching the film that I didn't pick up from the songs or the show!

 

I saw Samantha Barks as Eponine in the West End and then she's playing the same in the film, which is quite 8)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Frances Ruffelle was in that role when I saw it Lewis, I have to say that I prefer Sam Barks' voice from what I've heard of it. I've never been a fan of Michael Ball (too full of himself) but Eddie Redmayne is quite yummy for a young lad. I'm getting really excited now.

 

Rosie is with her dad this weekend, she wanted to see it so I invited them along but he seems to have vetoed it :roll:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can see how it could be confusing if you don't know the show or haven't heard the songs, but I realised some things watching the film that I didn't pick up from the songs or the show!

 

quote

 

As far as I could tell from my one exposure...there was no resolution (which I found ultimately unsatisfying) one character achieves redemption early on...the other doesn't and then acts obsessively and eventually throws everything he stand for away..not sure why?

 

Edited to add...sorry on rereading this seems very negative..didn't mean it to be so...

 

I love marmite and I didn't hate this film... but I didn't love it either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spoiler alert do not read any further if you don't know the story !

 

Sadietoo - I think I now have the measure of javert having seen the stage show twice and now the film (which I absolutely loved )

 

Javert thinks that a criminal is always a criminal and when he finally realises that Valjean is truly a good man he can't cope with it as it turns his core beliefs upside down and he ends it all

 

I thought the film was astonishing. Russell Crowe was the weakest for me. Anne hathaway's rendition of I dreamed a dream was truly haunting, Eddie Redmayne and Hugh Jackman were brilliant . Everyone clapped at the end. I felt like standing up and joining in with the song !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spoiler alert do not read any further if you don't know the story !

 

Sadietoo - I think I now have the measure of javert having seen the stage show twice and now the film (which I absolutely loved )

 

Javert thinks that a criminal is always a criminal and when he finally realises that Valjean is truly a good man he can't cope with it as it turns his core beliefs upside down and he ends it all

 

Thanks Chickendoodle for the explaination , but my problem with it is that I can't see how a professed Christian such as Javert (first song about Lucifer falling etc) would commit suicide and condemn himself ((by his own belief) to hell..... no matter the provocation.... it just doesn't make any sense to me, and weakens the whole plot imo....

 

Anyway, the songs have stayed with me today, and I still have some images from the film in my head, so it must have impressed me at some level.....Glad everyone who already loves the show is enjoying the film...it's so disappointing when things don't live up to your expectations. One thing that a critic said,and I think it is a valid point and would have added to my personal enjoyment, is that the stage show benefits from an intermission...if only this film had had one. Does anyone remember the days when a film had an intermission...I remember Sound of Music did when it first came out!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm with Chickendoodle here. Sorry haven't read all posts yet. Just got back in from seeing it- fantastic!!!

Seen the stage show twice and never quite got the plot. I think for me what made the difference was the clarity of the enunciation in the film, so I understood every word; especially when different characters were singing their version of events (Sorry Emeli Sande!)

 

I didn't see Javert as a professed Christian, more a man than had been born in a prison and felt that all prisoners were life's detritus and incapable of change. Perhaps we needed his backstory but then I don't think Victor Hugo wrote one as such.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also I hadn't realised that Marius had a rich family home with a Father. I could never work out how Valjean rescued him but Marius never knew it was him (always assumed that he recovered in Valjean's house). The film made it clear that he recovered in his family home

 

Always thought that the barricades depicted were part of the revolution and had some point but it seems that they were just a hopeless stand and a tragic waste of young lives

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Went last night, never seen the stage show, and didn't know the plot at all, only realised this week that "I dreamed" was a song from les Mis. (philistine)

Loved it., Thought H Jackmans ' voice was not the strongest, Eddie R was mesmerising, and the passion of youth, both romantically, and politically, was portrayed with such force...

Sad film though, really, as everyone has so much to bear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also I hadn't realised that Marius had a rich family home with a Father. I could never work out how Valjean rescued him but Marius never knew it was him (always assumed that he recovered in Valjean's house). The film made it clear that he recovered in his family home

 

Always thought that the barricades depicted were part of the revolution and had some point but it seems that they were just a hopeless stand and a tragic waste of young lives

Tiannanmen Square in a previous life perhaps?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Subjected OH this on Sat night. I loved it!!!

 

I have seen the stage version and cried a bit in that. I sobbed at least 4 times in the film and couldn't stop at the end, hubby was thrilled with that :oops::lol:

 

I understood much more of the plot after watching the film, can't believe how well they converted it.

 

Just to warn you Dogmother that not all partners agree on this film :wink: Mr Mostin said it was the most depressing and miserable 2 1/2 hours of his life :lol::lol::lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always thought the final straw re Javert was after Valjean let him go free at the barricade ? Still not managed to see the film yet as I have an ear infection but still looking forward to it.

 

Those who have been my friend read reviews saying it was too noisey ?? It won't bother me as I had a music teacher whose rule regarding classical and musicals that they had to be listened to at full volume :-) so much to hubbbys disappointment that's what I do :-) but my friend is worried she won't enjoy the film because of this ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.





×
×
  • Create New...